Any takers for education?

When I left my first school after class 10 to join a Kendriya Vidyalaya (Central School), I had no idea what I was getting into. At best, I’d been a reluctant student and I figured that my indifference to academics stemmed from the fact that so many of the subjects that I’d studied were not of my choice. I was terrified of math and science gave me nightmares. So when I joined KV, I assumed the going would be easy from now on. After all, I was studying Humanities…I loved stuff like history, geography and economics, ergo I’d enjoy studying it all.

Well, I wasn’t wrong. I loved academia. I stayed up till late in the night studying and having the time of my life. But what I hadn’t counted on was the school itself. What a nightmare! Firstly, it was more a fish market than anything else. My old school (Prakash Higher Secondary School a.k.a PHSS for convenience) had the air of a chapel..quiet and decorous. Sure it was not as big as KV and did not have all the infrastructure that the latter had to offer, but the students were infinitely better. More serious, more intellectual and more non-violent. Yes Reader, the last two words are ‘non-violent’. For judge of my horror and dismay, when I learned that this new school of mine had thugs and goons as its students – people who did not thinking twice before pasting another person one on the nose! Fist fights and blood shed (minor) were a regular feature of school life. ( I saw a classmate being dragged off by one of his ‘enemies’ and being pounded into a pulp. I was scarred for life). The motto of this school apparently was ‘Anything Goes.’

———————————————

Speaking of schools, there was an article in today’s Times of India, Mumbai edition, about the poor performance of state-run schools in Maharashtra. The following are the statistics provided by the newspaper

  • 6.5 lakh class-I students in Maharashtra didn’t understand the meaning of the English sentence: “Show me your pencil.”
  • 5.6 lakh class-II students could not read the number ‘8’ in English.
  • In class III, 5.8 lakh students could not fill in the blank between the alphabet ‘d’ and the alphabet ‘g’ (‘d____g’).

While I know what Mark Twain said about statistics, I don’t think this news report is very wide off the mark. When I was in class XII, my classmates had trouble framing even simple sentences in English. The problem to a large extent lay with the teaching methodology. In many schools, English is almost always taught in Hindi. While students are encouraged to answer questions in English, they’re never taught to think in English. Also, students are not encouraged to read much. The exam-driven academic culture ingrains it in students that any reading, apart from that directly related to studies, is frivolous. How then will students learn English? Not every word in the dictionary, not every turn of phrase can be taught in the classroom. I remember in my first school we had a ‘library period’ in which we were all supposed to take books from the library and read. Many so-called studious pupils got those classes cancelled because they thought it would be better to study and to finish homework during that class than to ‘waste’ it reading books! The logic defied me.

Of course, there are those who wonder why we should read ‘foreign literature’ in an ‘alien language’. But that is fodder for another post!
Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Any takers for education?

  1. Shocking figures that, thought, it doesn’t come much as a surprise!

    And less said about my school, the better it is… U already know it… Some similarities between our schools!!!

  2. the Indian education system sucks! Unfortunately, there’s nuthin v can do abt it until it passes from those rotund politicians 2 us students, yeah?

    And whoa! Are all KV’s famous for fisticuffs? The KV close 2 my place has its share of ruffians too!

    It seems a really long time since 3rd standard, but I have a hunch the answer to ‘d____g’ is ‘dawg’ ?

  3. Traditionally..it is ‘d-e-f-g’..but who knows? the state that education is in right now, it may well be ‘dawg’!!

  4. What are those numbers as percentages? In absolute numbers I find them as shocking as you probably do, but if these are out of 50 lakh students, I would not be as disheartened. And is there any overlap between those numbers? I would not be surprised if the 5.6 was a subset of the 5.8 which in turn was a subset of the 6.5.

    The Times of India is the most pathetic excuse for a newspaper the journalistic world has ever seen. IMHO.

  5. The total number would not really matter cause remember these are students who go to state run schools. It doesn’t matter if the number is out of 50 lakh or a crore… the fact is they go to schools and still does not know the basics!!! which in itself is shocking!

    And Pooja, u r rite in sayin “the newspaper report is not very wide off the mark.” There is every possibility that the numbers would actually much more than that!

  6. Varun, you’re absolutely right when you say TOI is a pathetic excuse for a newspaper. Normally, I take all its reports with a pinch of salt. But the point here is, that I have seen what the newspaper says is the case. I agree it’s just one school…but it was a state-run school. Of course, I maybe wrong…but I don’t think so.

  7. I think the total number is very important, because it gives an indication as to the effectiveness of the state-run schools. If 10% of the students don’t know the alphabet, as opposed to 80%, the implications are quite different.

    The TOI comment was just an out of context expression of frustration.

    “I agree it’s just one school”
    6.5 lakh kids in one school?

    And Pooja, I would never, ever even dream of insinuating that you could possibly be anything but 100% correct.

  8. When I said it’s just one school, I meant the school I studied at.

    We all know that newspapers generally tend to give us absolute figures as opposed to percentages, because the former create more of an impact. That, of course, does not mean that we accept all the figures that they throw at us.
    The point is that considering my experience in one school ( that’s why I made the comment – ‘it’s just one school’), I would say that what TOI says is not very far from the truth. In this situation, whether the figures are absolute or not does not make much of a difference, in my opinion. The picture is still dismal.

  9. fun debate u ppl seem 2 hve had…
    da figures leave me SHOCKD!!
    don’t think dat hppnd in any of da skools i studied in…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s